↔
Title: “We Learn It Too Late” – 5 Regrets Trapping People From A Life Of Purpose & Meaning | Gabor Maté
Duration: 01:18:39
Total Correct Answers:
Current Caption
Correct
Learning Modes
YouTube Video Transcript Hide
Ask AI:
Export as:
Ask AI Result
The ask AI result will appear here..
(00:00:00) Your YouTube transcript will appear here
(00:00:00)
Gabel you turned 80 yeah a few months
(00:00:03)
ago two months ago yeah how is that for
(00:00:07)
you
(00:00:10)
um you know we had a really nice party
(00:00:13)
um and my children came and they wrote
(00:00:15)
us some songs and they performed them
(00:00:17)
and uh close friends were there it was
(00:00:19)
very warm we had wonderful Palestinian
(00:00:22)
food uh catered and uh it was a really
(00:00:25)
good time and it
(00:00:28)
felt it felt like I arrived somewhere
(00:00:30)
you know and
(00:00:33)
uh nobody ever imagines being 80 I mean
(00:00:36)
do you imagine ever being 80 yeah it's
(00:00:39)
funny as you you ask that question no
(00:00:42)
you think about lots of things in life I
(00:00:44)
do imagine sometimes what it might be
(00:00:45)
like when my wife and I are old and what
(00:00:48)
we might do together but no I can't I
(00:00:51)
can't say I've ever imagined actually
(00:00:53)
being 80 years old yeah and at some
(00:00:56)
point it would have struck me as such an
(00:00:58)
impossibly U geriatric number you know
(00:01:02)
at this point is just a number you know
(00:01:04)
and it's it's almost
(00:01:06)
meaningless except it's not completely
(00:01:08)
meaningless because I know that the time
(00:01:12)
is one always knows that the time is
(00:01:15)
limited intellectually we understand is
(00:01:16)
that nobody lives forever and we never
(00:01:19)
know when the reaper is going to come
(00:01:21)
knocking on your door but at the same
(00:01:23)
time once you get to be 80 you realize
(00:01:26)
that whenever it's going to happen it's
(00:01:27)
going to happen within a fairly short
(00:01:29)
period of time and when I think of when
(00:01:31)
I retired from active Medical Practice
(00:01:34)
it was um 13 years ago now well will I
(00:01:39)
still be alive 13 years from now and it
(00:01:42)
seems like just a short period of time
(00:01:44)
so when you think about it it's quite um
(00:01:49)
dramatic but on the other hand from the
(00:01:51)
moment to moment and day to day it just
(00:01:53)
doesn't make any difference
(00:01:56)
yeah there's something about the number
(00:01:58)
80 yeah I think
(00:02:01)
and of course we know it's just another
(00:02:02)
day and it's just a number but does
(00:02:06)
something change when you wake up and
(00:02:09)
your family and your friends celebrate
(00:02:11)
hey Gaba you're now 80 years old yeah
(00:02:15)
does it in some way change the way you
(00:02:17)
see yourself or or I guess reflect
(00:02:20)
differently on who you are and where you
(00:02:22)
are in your
(00:02:23)
life and most days I can say this and
(00:02:26)
not on every day for sure but it's a
(00:02:29)
kind of ease enter in my life even with
(00:02:32)
all that's going on in the world I'm
(00:02:33)
just sort of
(00:02:35)
more I don't struggle with the way
(00:02:37)
things are so much I may like them or
(00:02:39)
not like them I may react or not respond
(00:02:41)
or but there's not a struggle against
(00:02:45)
just the beingness of
(00:02:48)
things um I'm certainly noticing that
(00:02:52)
yeah and and uh people I had a visitor a
(00:02:57)
week ago who I hadn't seen for a few
(00:02:59)
years and she says youve changed and I
(00:03:01)
said oh yeah she say you've become
(00:03:03)
softer you know and um if that's true
(00:03:07)
it's it's good it's a sign of kind of
(00:03:10)
loosening
(00:03:13)
inside you used to work in paliative
(00:03:16)
care yeah and I think you're familiar
(00:03:20)
with the book by bronnie we the palive
(00:03:22)
care nurse five regrets of the dying
(00:03:25)
yeah what I thought would be
(00:03:27)
interesting today for our fourth convers
(00:03:30)
a on my podcast together yeah is to
(00:03:33)
maybe go through each of those five
(00:03:34)
regrets because I I just I'd love to
(00:03:38)
know from your perspective what each of
(00:03:41)
these regrets says yeah about where we
(00:03:44)
are who we are yeah what things were
(00:03:48)
important to us yeah and so the first of
(00:03:51)
those five regrets is I wish I had the
(00:03:53)
courage to live a life true to myself
(00:03:56)
not the life others expected of me yeah
(00:04:00)
and so let's keep in mind
(00:04:03)
that like when I used to work in Pala of
(00:04:06)
care which I did for seven years and
(00:04:08)
this nurse who wrote the book she's AUST
(00:04:11)
tralian and she wrote the book about 12
(00:04:13)
years ago now they weren't talking about
(00:04:16)
people dying at old age they were mostly
(00:04:18)
it's about people dying before their
(00:04:20)
time MH and so the regrets that they had
(00:04:24)
um as their terminal illness usually
(00:04:26)
malignancy or perhaps chronic autoimmune
(00:04:29)
disease
(00:04:30)
um brought them to the end of their
(00:04:34)
physical
(00:04:35)
existence what did they regret and the
(00:04:37)
top one was I wish I had the courage to
(00:04:40)
live my own life rather than the one
(00:04:41)
that people expected of
(00:04:44)
me I would reframe
(00:04:47)
that because there's a deep truth in it
(00:04:50)
and as you know and perhaps we've talked
(00:04:53)
about from my point of view very often
(00:04:56)
the people that do develop chronic
(00:04:58)
illness are people that have their own
(00:05:00)
true s for the sake of being accepted to
(00:05:03)
others and that self-suppression has
(00:05:05)
deep physiological consequences on the
(00:05:07)
immune system on the nervous system on
(00:05:08)
the heart and so on so that that
(00:05:11)
self-suppression is also physiological
(00:05:14)
self annihilation in some
(00:05:16)
ways but when she talks about courage
(00:05:20)
that's a self- judgment they're saying
(00:05:22)
to themselves I wish it had the courage
(00:05:25)
as if it was a question of cowardice it
(00:05:27)
isn't it's a question of programming
(00:05:30)
like you and I are both parents we know
(00:05:34)
this no infant is born suppressing
(00:05:36)
themselves no infant enters the first
(00:05:40)
day on this Earth trying to please
(00:05:43)
anybody they're just being purely
(00:05:45)
themselves yeah expressing their Joy
(00:05:48)
when it's there expressing their upset
(00:05:50)
their distress when that's dominant but
(00:05:52)
they're purely themselves so that what
(00:05:55)
she calls courage or what these people
(00:05:57)
call courage of being myself is actually
(00:06:00)
a trauma imprint that for some reason
(00:06:03)
they learned early in life that to be
(00:06:05)
themselves is to court rejection by
(00:06:09)
their environment so it's not a lack of
(00:06:12)
Courage you can't talk about a
(00:06:13)
one-year-old lacking courage or a
(00:06:15)
two-year-old it's simply an
(00:06:18)
adaptation now later on they say courage
(00:06:21)
but really that's
(00:06:23)
a that courage is or the lack of it is a
(00:06:26)
shorthand for something happened to me
(00:06:29)
that I gave up my true self for the sake
(00:06:32)
of being accepted and that cost me
(00:06:37)
uh first of all it cost them in terms of
(00:06:39)
physical illness but also cost them in
(00:06:41)
terms of self-respect and and dignity
(00:06:45)
it's a major one yeah are you living a
(00:06:48)
life at the moment that's true to
(00:06:51)
yourself I am now um uh I I sense that I
(00:06:56)
have I believe that I am um
(00:07:00)
that doesn't mean every second I do you
(00:07:02)
know but on the whole I do and it feels
(00:07:06)
really good and I know you know I had
(00:07:10)
dinner last night and and and you were
(00:07:11)
telling me that you're finding
(00:07:14)
yourself far more self expressed and and
(00:07:19)
and comfortable with who you are than
(00:07:21)
you used to so that's the good news
(00:07:24)
people is that this is a process that
(00:07:26)
can continue for a lifetime yeah but
(00:07:28)
yeah um
(00:07:32)
I I really see that people who suppress
(00:07:35)
themselves really suffer
(00:07:38)
yeah so that first regret I wish I had
(00:07:41)
the courage to live a life true to
(00:07:42)
myself um I'm really glad you picked out
(00:07:45)
the word courage because that word also
(00:07:47)
stands out to me yeah it's very
(00:07:49)
interesting to use that words yeah um
(00:07:52)
well it's a self judgment isn't it it is
(00:07:55)
you know I could have done better I
(00:07:57)
should have had the courage is what that
(00:07:59)
kind of says
(00:08:01)
yeah it's interesting you said when when
(00:08:03)
you turned
(00:08:05)
80 or as a consequence of you turning 80
(00:08:08)
you realize that well 13 years ago you
(00:08:10)
gave it your medical practice yeah will
(00:08:13)
you be alive in 13 years that's very
(00:08:16)
striking yeah are you afraid of death
(00:08:21)
um in principle I'm not you know um but
(00:08:26)
I don't really know till I have to face
(00:08:27)
it I won't know how afraid I am until it
(00:08:30)
confronts me you know at this point I
(00:08:34)
feel healthy and I get to do what I want
(00:08:36)
to do
(00:08:37)
and I have Vigor and I have interests
(00:08:40)
and excitement and and love and and um
(00:08:45)
likes and dislikes and I'm quite alive
(00:08:48)
you
(00:08:49)
know what happens when I have to
(00:08:51)
confront the actuality of it I have no
(00:08:54)
idea how I'm going to respond so it's
(00:08:58)
sometimes I get fear around it I mean
(00:09:00)
there's I don't want to give this up I
(00:09:01)
don't want to give up this
(00:09:03)
life but other times I say well if I do
(00:09:08)
I've lived and it's been good and
(00:09:10)
there's not much to regret you know so
(00:09:13)
yes and no but I won't really know until
(00:09:15)
I'm up against
(00:09:17)
it you've spoken publicly before
(00:09:22)
about your um your Journeys with plant
(00:09:26)
medicine
(00:09:27)
yeah does that change anything
(00:09:30)
for you I guess or has that changed
(00:09:32)
anything in terms of how you may view
(00:09:35)
what happens at the end of human life
(00:09:38)
because people many people will say for
(00:09:40)
them it does change how they perceive
(00:09:42)
themselves how they perceive death how
(00:09:44)
they perceive what this experience of
(00:09:47)
life actually really is well
(00:09:49)
specifically as you're probably aware
(00:09:52)
they've done studies on Endo life
(00:09:54)
anxiety with Salos cybin so-called magic
(00:09:57)
mushrooms and um
(00:10:01)
people report spiritual experiences yeah
(00:10:04)
and people report a significant
(00:10:07)
abatement of anxiety they had on di
(00:10:09)
these are people who terminally ill and
(00:10:12)
uh nothing that the medical profession
(00:10:14)
could offer
(00:10:17)
to reverse the course of their fatal
(00:10:21)
Illness but they had much less anxiety
(00:10:23)
about dying as a result of those
(00:10:26)
spiritual
(00:10:27)
experiences that were induced by taking
(00:10:29)
them mushroom yeah uh for
(00:10:32)
me I've never faced death in that sense
(00:10:36)
when I think of some of my psych like
(00:10:38)
experiences and if in retrospect I allow
(00:10:41)
myself to sink into them I can say in
(00:10:45)
that state that would not be afraid of
(00:10:48)
death I'd say that there's a larger
(00:10:51)
reality than
(00:10:54)
the persistence or sensation of this
(00:10:57)
particular lung m
(00:11:00)
uh represents you know I would say that
(00:11:02)
if I project myself back into those
(00:11:05)
experiences again how I will face it
(00:11:07)
when it happens or when it becomes
(00:11:12)
inevitable um I don't know
(00:11:15)
yeah
(00:11:17)
society's view or this society's view of
(00:11:21)
people getting older yeah 80 seems to be
(00:11:25)
the age where we often expect people to
(00:11:28)
be doing less
(00:11:30)
you know being less mobile less vital
(00:11:34)
not everyone of course but but many you
(00:11:37)
seem to be someone who has
(00:11:40)
this love of life this Vigor this
(00:11:43)
message you want to share you seem to be
(00:11:45)
traveling all over the
(00:11:47)
globe at you know pretty regular
(00:11:51)
intervals you youve come to London for 4
(00:11:53)
days you going help me do some teaching
(00:11:55)
with doctors tomorrow which is
(00:11:56)
incredible but a lot of 80-year-olds are
(00:11:58)
not doing that
(00:12:00)
yeah
(00:12:01)
right and the longevity space within
(00:12:05)
medicine has really exploded over the
(00:12:07)
last few
(00:12:08)
years people love talking about
(00:12:10)
longevity right and I think we're
(00:12:14)
missing something in our discussions
(00:12:17)
about longevity well I think there's a
(00:12:19)
couple of things what what do you think
(00:12:20)
we're missing I
(00:12:22)
think it depends what you mean by
(00:12:24)
longevous first of all right so yes some
(00:12:27)
people want to know how can I not
(00:12:29)
necessarily live longer but be
(00:12:32)
independent mobile vital as long as I
(00:12:35)
live so Health span versus lifespan yeah
(00:12:37)
and I get that yeah but there's a lot of
(00:12:40)
talk these days about extending lifespan
(00:12:43)
living to 150 and Beyond and all kinds
(00:12:46)
of crazy stuff right and I don't want to
(00:12:48)
be the I don't want to stand in the way
(00:12:50)
of human progress at
(00:12:51)
all my one of my phase is that in
(00:12:55)
Pursuit Of Living
(00:12:58)
longer are we missing something about
(00:13:02)
the Beauty and the essence of what life
(00:13:04)
really is life is finite the fact that
(00:13:07)
it's finite is what makes it so
(00:13:10)
beautiful yeah if we could live to 200
(00:13:14)
yeah would we have even more of these
(00:13:16)
regrets because we'd keep taking life
(00:13:18)
for granted you know what I you're
(00:13:21)
talking my language because to tell you
(00:13:24)
the truth to coin a phrase all this
(00:13:26)
stuff about longevity bores me to death
(00:13:28)
you know um I just don't care you
(00:13:33)
know what really matters is what does
(00:13:36)
this moment bring us or what can we
(00:13:38)
bring to this moment you know let the
(00:13:40)
future take care of itself you know like
(00:13:42)
Jesus says take no thought for tomorrow
(00:13:45)
you know and um I really think that this
(00:13:50)
longevity movement is a sign of deep
(00:13:52)
social anxiety and especially you get
(00:13:55)
these rich people in California with
(00:13:57)
their
(00:13:58)
cryo technology of freezing the body
(00:14:02)
hoping that 100 years from now they'll
(00:14:04)
be able to unfrozen and there'll be
(00:14:05)
treatments for the you know it bores me
(00:14:09)
you know what really matters is for me
(00:14:12)
is what makes life meaningful and active
(00:14:15)
and engaged in the present moment and um
(00:14:20)
it's interesting in
(00:14:22)
English we talk about growing
(00:14:25)
older now that's a very telling phrase
(00:14:28)
because
(00:14:30)
in significant ways when we get older we
(00:14:33)
shrink you know like our
(00:14:35)
bodies our skin starts to Sag our
(00:14:38)
muscles are no longer as you
(00:14:41)
know Supple and strong as they used to
(00:14:44)
be so what does it mean to grow
(00:14:47)
older we could just say like you said
(00:14:50)
earlier get older which is just a
(00:14:51)
chronological progression but growing
(00:14:54)
older implies that this growth is
(00:14:56)
actually possible so in what sense can
(00:14:58)
we actually grow grow and I think
(00:15:01)
actually we can actually grow into the
(00:15:03)
present moment and and and growing in
(00:15:05)
our grow our appreciation for life and
(00:15:09)
what matters and and knowing what
(00:15:11)
doesn't matter and growing in wisdom
(00:15:13)
indigenous cultures they don't talk
(00:15:16)
about elderly they talk about Elders
(00:15:18)
yeah a huge difference yeah so um I
(00:15:23)
think there's
(00:15:24)
a natural reverence for age that senior
(00:15:28)
cultures would respect and modern
(00:15:31)
society kind of
(00:15:34)
um dismisses you know now do I wish that
(00:15:37)
my hair was blacker and more curly the
(00:15:40)
way it used to be yeah I do you know and
(00:15:43)
it wasn't gray and my hair wasn't
(00:15:45)
thinning at the top and I sure I wish
(00:15:47)
that
(00:15:49)
but H at the same time I would not going
(00:15:52)
to be as unconscious as I was yeah when
(00:15:56)
my hair was blacker and curlier you know
(00:15:59)
yeah this is such an interesting point
(00:16:01)
I've spoken to several menopause experts
(00:16:07)
on the show oh yeah over the past
(00:16:09)
years and I remember when doing some
(00:16:11)
research on one of the conversations I
(00:16:12)
came across research showing that in
(00:16:15)
cultures where women are revered as they
(00:16:19)
get older yeah their wisdom is respected
(00:16:22)
they're seen as really important parts
(00:16:25)
of the community right those cultures
(00:16:27)
report less menopausal symptoms isn't
(00:16:31)
that interesting I just so I'm not
(00:16:33)
misinterpreted I want to be really clear
(00:16:36)
I'm not saying that that means that all
(00:16:38)
menopausal symptoms would go away if
(00:16:40)
that was the case I just find it
(00:16:42)
interesting that when the cultural view
(00:16:46)
of growing old is different yeah we
(00:16:50)
perceive ourselves as having I don't
(00:16:53)
know a different symptom profile if if I
(00:16:56)
can put it like that and and and and the
(00:16:57)
degree of suffering is different
(00:16:59)
so that maybe they have symptoms or
(00:17:02)
maybe they have certain features but the
(00:17:05)
suffering is not experienced the same
(00:17:08)
way please expand on that because I
(00:17:09)
think some people will go what do you
(00:17:11)
mean if you're either getting symptoms
(00:17:12)
or you're not getting symptoms explain
(00:17:14)
what you mean by perception of you know
(00:17:17)
the the suffering essentially well I was
(00:17:19)
talking to somebody else about this
(00:17:20)
today so in as you as you and I know in
(00:17:25)
Western medicine we kind of medicalize
(00:17:27)
everything and so we talk about
(00:17:29)
premenstrual syndrome not which PMS it's
(00:17:35)
a syndrome it's a medical entity what is
(00:17:38)
it really is that under the impact of
(00:17:40)
hormonal changes women get more
(00:17:43)
sensitized so they might have more
(00:17:45)
physical pain and more
(00:17:49)
upset but we can see that as
(00:17:52)
pathological or we could actually say
(00:17:54)
that it's a time of
(00:17:58)
truthtellah ize them to things that are
(00:18:00)
not functioning in in their lives which
(00:18:03)
the rest of the time they are curated to
(00:18:05)
acous with and to put up with yeah but
(00:18:08)
the menstrual ferment in their bodies
(00:18:11)
makes it less tolerable so instead of
(00:18:13)
seeing that as a pathology we could see
(00:18:15)
it as a time of insight and what if they
(00:18:18)
actually listen to their bodies and
(00:18:21)
listen to what their body saying know to
(00:18:24)
that the rest of the month they kind of
(00:18:27)
suppress then that could be seen as a
(00:18:29)
time of wisdom rather than a time of
(00:18:32)
suffering so
(00:18:33)
the the physical things are there but
(00:18:37)
but it doesn't have to be experienced as
(00:18:39)
suffering could be experienced as a time
(00:18:41)
of
(00:18:48)
truthtotable menopause as well yeah this
(00:18:51)
kind of speaks to the second regret
(00:18:53)
which is I wish I hadn't worked so hard
(00:18:55)
yeah
(00:18:57)
and what I mean by that
(00:19:00)
is I agree
(00:19:04)
that for many women
(00:19:07)
yeah and I can think of so many patients
(00:19:10)
like this them their hormonal
(00:19:14)
symptoms we actually showing them that
(00:19:18)
the way you're currently living is not
(00:19:20)
in harmony with your body exactly now of
(00:19:23)
course sometimes people struggle to make
(00:19:25)
change it's hard to make change maybe
(00:19:26)
their life is Mega stressful and at that
(00:19:29)
moment they can't change it for whatever
(00:19:30)
reason and I totally I empathize with
(00:19:33)
that I I understand yeah but for some
(00:19:36)
people who are able to it's in sometimes
(00:19:40)
it's one of the best things that has
(00:19:41)
happened to them yeah now this thing of
(00:19:43)
I wish I hadn't worked so
(00:19:45)
hard that's an interesting one because I
(00:19:48)
wish I hadn't worked so hard and what do
(00:19:50)
I mean by that
(00:19:52)
like like
(00:19:54)
uh speaking for myself and I don't know
(00:19:57)
if this is true for you but I became a
(00:19:59)
physician for some really good reasons
(00:20:02)
one of them was I genuinely wanted to
(00:20:04)
help suffering humanity and I thought
(00:20:06)
medicine is a
(00:20:10)
perfect pathway through which I could
(00:20:13)
help people that's genuine and I meant
(00:20:16)
it I
(00:20:18)
also chose a profession where I was
(00:20:20)
fairly confident of making a decent
(00:20:22)
living so I could support
(00:20:24)
a a life for myself and my family that's
(00:20:28)
legitimate
(00:20:31)
but those reasons don't make you work
(00:20:32)
too hard they make you work hard but
(00:20:35)
they don't make you work too hard what
(00:20:38)
makes you work too hard and that's what
(00:20:39)
these people are saying is you're driven
(00:20:42)
by something that you're not even aware
(00:20:44)
of and what I wasn't aware of when I
(00:20:46)
went to medical school and when I was a
(00:20:49)
physician for decades is how driven I
(00:20:53)
was to justify my existence in the world
(00:20:56)
and to prove her that I was important
(00:20:58)
and worthwhile
(00:20:59)
and so on and that had to do with the
(00:21:02)
loss of those that confidence owing to
(00:21:04)
Early Childhood trauma and so the it's
(00:21:07)
not a question nobody says I wish I W
(00:21:10)
hadn't worked hard to achieve something
(00:21:13)
in life you have to work hard they're
(00:21:15)
saying I wish I worked too hard and that
(00:21:18)
to part the Too part comes from being
(00:21:22)
driven by unconscious needs to validate
(00:21:25)
Your Existence where why should any
(00:21:27)
human being have to validate their
(00:21:29)
existence you know and so that's what
(00:21:32)
they're saying and when you're driven to
(00:21:34)
work too hard you actually ignore what
(00:21:37)
matters and what matters is um what you
(00:21:41)
were telling me last night about how
(00:21:43)
much it matters for you to spend time
(00:21:45)
with your family so every summer you
(00:21:47)
take a bunch of weeks away from your
(00:21:49)
podcast and you just spend time enjoying
(00:21:52)
your kids and and and your wife and your
(00:21:55)
family and I didn't do that I for me was
(00:21:59)
very hard to even take holidays I always
(00:22:01)
felt they had to keep working if
(00:22:03)
somebody was in pregnant my God what if
(00:22:06)
I would miss their delivery like the
(00:22:07)
baby couldn't enter the world without me
(00:22:09)
you know so that drivenness is what
(00:22:11)
makes people work too hard and so not a
(00:22:15)
matter of working hard it's a matter of
(00:22:16)
working too hard and where does that
(00:22:18)
come from a gain that comes from
(00:22:19)
childhood trauma a lot of doctors and I
(00:22:23)
have several friends like this they
(00:22:25)
don't take their full allowance of
(00:22:29)
annual
(00:22:29)
leave sounds like you may have been
(00:22:32)
similar I had that tendency yeah yeah
(00:22:35)
and often people will
(00:22:37)
say and I have a friend who says this
(00:22:40)
yeah but my patients need me no they
(00:22:42)
don't need them they need medical help
(00:22:45)
yeah but I think we have to ask
(00:22:47)
ourselves and this is very very common
(00:22:49)
in medicine actually I'm sure it's
(00:22:51)
common in other um professions as well
(00:22:54)
yeah it's interesting when you don't
(00:22:56)
take your full allowance of annual leave
(00:22:58)
that your contract entitles you to it's
(00:23:01)
often paid time off right it's part of
(00:23:03)
your job when you're not taking it of
(00:23:07)
course there can be reasons for that
(00:23:09)
there can be reasonable reasons there
(00:23:10)
can be work reasons but if you're not I
(00:23:12)
think you I think it may be worth
(00:23:14)
reflecting on some of those
(00:23:17)
underlying you know those real drivers
(00:23:20)
of that well it occurs to me that what
(00:23:23)
your friend is actually saying is not
(00:23:25)
that my patients need me but I need my
(00:23:27)
patients yeah to feel okay and when I'm
(00:23:31)
not working to help them I don't know
(00:23:34)
who I am and I don't feel comfortable
(00:23:36)
myself so I need them now that means get
(00:23:39)
it to a therapist and deal with it and
(00:23:41)
and not only that even Your Capacity to
(00:23:44)
help your patience over time will be
(00:23:46)
eroded toally by the way you're
(00:23:48)
stressing yourself and you're not taking
(00:23:50)
care of yourself and Physicians are
(00:23:52)
notoriously programmed to ignore
(00:23:55)
themselves and there was a very
(00:23:56)
interesting study that I mentioned in
(00:23:58)
the book The Myth of normal they looked
(00:24:00)
at the fraying of the
(00:24:04)
chromosomes um of people and you know
(00:24:09)
when we're born we were born with
(00:24:11)
certain structures called telome and
(00:24:13)
telome are DNA structures at the end of
(00:24:16)
our chromosomes and their fraying and
(00:24:19)
their shortening is a mark of aging and
(00:24:21)
of stress and they looked at the the
(00:24:23)
telome of medical residents compared to
(00:24:26)
other people their age they age f faster
(00:24:29)
they Fray
(00:24:30)
faster and so Physicians are driven to
(00:24:34)
actually
(00:24:36)
um not spare themselves and to literally
(00:24:41)
consume themselves in the work in the
(00:24:43)
long term that may make you a very
(00:24:45)
popular and very successful doctor in
(00:24:47)
the long term it's going to be at the
(00:24:49)
expense of your marriage and of your
(00:24:51)
children and of your own mental and
(00:24:53)
physical
(00:24:55)
health for me if I look at that
(00:24:57)
situation and I
(00:24:59)
reflect on
(00:25:01)
society and
(00:25:03)
culture what I see these days is a
(00:25:07)
very it's very me focused culture where
(00:25:11)
Community has been gradually eroded out
(00:25:15)
yeah and therefore if we think about a
(00:25:18)
human being a human being needs to feel
(00:25:20)
that there of value to other people we
(00:25:23)
need that
(00:25:25)
it's in our
(00:25:27)
tribes you know 50,000 years ago we
(00:25:31)
would have felt of value because we
(00:25:34)
would have a role and other people would
(00:25:36)
see that role they would benefit from it
(00:25:38)
and we would benefit from the things
(00:25:40)
they were doing you know whether it's
(00:25:41)
someone's hunting someone's Gathering
(00:25:43)
someone's putting the fire on whatever
(00:25:44)
it might
(00:25:45)
be in this me Focus culture where it's
(00:25:48)
all me me me and what are my needs and
(00:25:50)
what do I need to do and how can I
(00:25:52)
better
(00:25:54)
myself I feel that we often don't feel a
(00:25:58)
Val to others we don't feel
(00:26:00)
important and so it makes sense that in
(00:26:03)
that culture you might overwork you
(00:26:06)
might keep pushing yourself because if
(00:26:08)
you're not working and feeling important
(00:26:11)
there then actually you may not have
(00:26:14)
that sensation in any other aspects of
(00:26:16)
your life well if well if you weren't
(00:26:19)
given the um it's very
(00:26:22)
simple if in early childhood you given
(00:26:25)
the sense that you're valued just
(00:26:27)
because you existed
(00:26:29)
your parents welcome you and validate
(00:26:30)
you and value you and and celebrate you
(00:26:33)
just because you
(00:26:34)
are then you don't have to keep proving
(00:26:36)
it afterwards MH but if you don't get
(00:26:38)
that sense then you have to be important
(00:26:41)
yeah so that sense of needing to be
(00:26:43)
important has to come from missing out
(00:26:45)
on being valued for who you are or being
(00:26:47)
only valued for your achievements you
(00:26:50)
know you're valued like look my parents
(00:26:53)
blessed their souls but they valued my
(00:26:56)
intelligence you know and so
(00:26:59)
so a lot of my Persona was caught up in
(00:27:03)
being smart and and proving my value
(00:27:06)
that way well it's good to be
(00:27:09)
intelligent but your value should
(00:27:11)
doesn't depend on or shouldn't depend on
(00:27:13)
any one quality whether you're cute or
(00:27:17)
cuddly or handsome or successful or good
(00:27:20)
at sports or smart in school any of that
(00:27:24)
your value is
(00:27:25)
intrinsic inate inherent cuz a human
(00:27:29)
being in a society as you say it tends
(00:27:32)
to Value people for what they do and so
(00:27:35)
that can become very very addictive but
(00:27:37)
again going back to your friend who says
(00:27:39)
my parent my patients need me and you
(00:27:42)
think about it and I'm not accusing them
(00:27:44)
of anything but they're not realizing
(00:27:47)
just egotistical that statement is is as
(00:27:50)
if it dependent on them their patients
(00:27:53)
need good medical care but they don't
(00:27:56)
need him or her or them specifically
(00:28:02)
which means that they should be able to
(00:28:04)
take care of themselves as long as they
(00:28:06)
make sure that when they're not there MH
(00:28:08)
their patients are receiving the care
(00:28:12)
that they need so it's not about us and
(00:28:14)
I used to think it was always about me
(00:28:16)
if I'm not there for the delivery of
(00:28:18)
this particular Woman's baby oh my God
(00:28:20)
you know like as if it all depended on
(00:28:24)
me there's probably a control issue
(00:28:25)
there as well isn't there that I I know
(00:28:27)
how I would do it exactly I need to be
(00:28:29)
there cuz I know how I would manage this
(00:28:31)
birth and that sort of stuff which is an
(00:28:33)
inability to let go exact someone else
(00:28:36)
can probably do this as well yeah or if
(00:28:38)
they can't do it as well so be it you
(00:28:40)
know so be it you know yeah as I was
(00:28:44)
walking to the studio this morning
(00:28:47)
thinking about our
(00:28:49)
conversation the word impressive kept
(00:28:52)
coming up for
(00:28:53)
me and I'm being reflecting on the word
(00:28:56)
impressive because again I think
(00:28:59)
culturally we we think it's a good thing
(00:29:01)
to impress others okay that bit of work
(00:29:04)
you did is impressive MH but actually if
(00:29:07)
you if you really unpick impressive or
(00:29:11)
certainly if I do
(00:29:14)
it it implies to me and maybe this is my
(00:29:18)
own bias because this is what I have
(00:29:20)
done for much of my life yeah I've
(00:29:23)
changed who I am in
(00:29:26)
order to impress others yeah I didn't
(00:29:30)
feel I impressed others by being myself
(00:29:33)
yeah I impressed them by changing yeah
(00:29:36)
so what comes up for you when you hear
(00:29:39)
the word impressive have we got it wrong
(00:29:42)
has it
(00:29:43)
been you know has it been taken to mean
(00:29:46)
something it's not like how how do you
(00:29:47)
see the word impressive
(00:29:49)
H well
(00:29:52)
[Music]
(00:29:53)
um impressive first of all has to do
(00:29:57)
with what it has to do with our impact
(00:29:59)
on other people how others see
(00:30:02)
us
(00:30:04)
so if I can just be myself and express
(00:30:07)
my own truth and not drive myself into
(00:30:12)
activities
(00:30:14)
that are not good for me and people are
(00:30:18)
impressed well that's
(00:30:19)
great but if my intention is to impress
(00:30:22)
other people if I need for me to make a
(00:30:27)
certain impression in somebody body
(00:30:28)
else's mind then where am I living that
(00:30:31)
I'm living in their minds rather than in
(00:30:33)
myself so the question is where do I
(00:30:36)
want to live here or in your mind you
(00:30:38)
know and uh our society is so
(00:30:43)
um addicted to people being impressive
(00:30:47)
in the minds of others that means that
(00:30:50)
we live in the minds of others don't
(00:30:52)
more than we live in ourselves so if I
(00:30:55)
can if you can be yourself and find out
(00:30:58)
if I find that impressive that's great
(00:31:00)
but you're not doing it to impress me
(00:31:02)
you're just doing it because that's
(00:31:03)
you're expressing who you are if I'm
(00:31:06)
impressed great if I'm not
(00:31:09)
impressed that doesn't take anything
(00:31:11)
away from you but to the degree that we
(00:31:13)
depend on impressing others we're
(00:31:17)
robbing
(00:31:18)
ourselves so that's how I see that word
(00:31:21)
just taking a quick break to give a
(00:31:23)
shout out to Vivo barefoot shoes now
(00:31:26)
I've been a huge fan of Vivo Barefoot
(00:31:28)
for over 10 years now well before they
(00:31:31)
started supporting my podcast they are
(00:31:33)
the only shoes that I wear and they
(00:31:35)
really have had a huge impact on my own
(00:31:37)
life and the lives of many of my
(00:31:40)
patients you see when people start
(00:31:42)
wearing Minimalist Shoes like vivos you
(00:31:45)
can see improvements in things like back
(00:31:47)
pain hip pain knee pain foot pain even
(00:31:51)
things like planta fasciitis can often
(00:31:53)
get better and scientific research shows
(00:31:56)
us that just wearing Vios for 4 months
(00:31:59)
or so improves the strength in your feet
(00:32:02)
by over 60% which is absolutely
(00:32:05)
incredible one thing people don't
(00:32:07)
realize about these shoes is just how
(00:32:09)
flexible they are which allows your feet
(00:32:11)
to do what your feet naturally want to
(00:32:13)
do rather than the shoe dictating your
(00:32:16)
foot's movement Vivo Barefoot are giving
(00:32:19)
my audience a 15% off onetime codes when
(00:32:23)
you make your first order and they make
(00:32:25)
it really easy for you to give them a
(00:32:27)
try they give a 100 day trial for new
(00:32:30)
customers so if you don't like them you
(00:32:33)
just send them back for a full refund
(00:32:35)
I'm a huge fan I really hope you take
(00:32:37)
advantage of this offer to get your 15%
(00:32:40)
off codes all you need to do is go to
(00:32:43)
Vivo
(00:32:57)
barfoot.co.nz my emotions yeah which is
(00:33:00)
I guess not dissimilar to the first one
(00:33:02)
about living a life that's true to
(00:33:04)
yourself no and it again it again
(00:33:07)
there's the word courage that shows up
(00:33:09)
and these people are judging
(00:33:13)
themselves and more interesting way to
(00:33:15)
put it is why is it that I didn't
(00:33:17)
express my feelings you know now here's
(00:33:20)
the thing um again in my writing in the
(00:33:24)
MTH of normal I quote this great
(00:33:26)
neuroscientist who died in his mid 70s
(00:33:30)
of cancer a few years ago those of us
(00:33:32)
who knew him still mourn him his name
(00:33:35)
was Dr Yak pank p n k s p p he was uh
(00:33:40)
from the Baltic states whether he was
(00:33:42)
Estonian I think he was but maybe latian
(00:33:46)
you know and he was an effective
(00:33:49)
neuroscientist so he studied the
(00:33:52)
neurobiology of
(00:33:55)
emotions and wrote a book called The
(00:33:57)
archaeology of the Mind it's one of the
(00:33:59)
seal books of modern science and he
(00:34:02)
pointed out that we share certain
(00:34:04)
emotional circuits with other
(00:34:06)
animals so we have circuit and he
(00:34:09)
capitalized these circuits these systems
(00:34:11)
so the c a r e the care system MH and
(00:34:16)
there was a system for
(00:34:18)
anger system for
(00:34:20)
fear for lust for playfulness for joy in
(00:34:25)
other words for seeking which is
(00:34:29)
curiosity um
(00:34:31)
grief and we share these brain circuits
(00:34:34)
with other mammals in other words these
(00:34:38)
emotions are not luxuries they are
(00:34:41)
emotionally I should say they are
(00:34:43)
evolutionally determined aspects of who
(00:34:46)
we are
(00:34:48)
so if you take the care
(00:34:51)
[Music]
(00:34:52)
system it's essential because without
(00:34:55)
care the Maman infant doesn't survive MH
(00:34:59)
there's got to be something in the
(00:35:00)
parent brain that drives that parent to
(00:35:02)
take care of the infant and something
(00:35:05)
that's in the infant's brain that impels
(00:35:08)
them to connect with the parent in order
(00:35:09)
to be taken care of that's just
(00:35:11)
evolutionary biology
(00:35:14)
so we have all these emotional systems
(00:35:17)
anger is one of them um as I mentioned
(00:35:20)
fear grief or
(00:35:23)
others and children one of the emotional
(00:35:25)
needs of children when I studied
(00:35:28)
and invest you know and interviewed
(00:35:31)
experts on Child Development one of the
(00:35:33)
things I learned and write about is that
(00:35:35)
one of the needs of children for healthy
(00:35:37)
brain development is the freedom to
(00:35:40)
experience and express all the emotions
(00:35:43)
that come up for them that's just
(00:35:45)
necessary for health um
(00:35:51)
now what happens in this Society where a
(00:35:54)
lot of parents get the message that
(00:35:56)
certain emotions on the part of their
(00:35:58)
their kids are not acceptable so you
(00:36:00)
know a kid might experience a loss like
(00:36:02)
a dog might die or grandpa might die and
(00:36:05)
the child is upset and the parent can't
(00:36:08)
handle the child's grief so snap out of
(00:36:10)
it it's just a dog or or you get over it
(00:36:15)
people die you know um or a child
(00:36:18)
experiences anger uh because you didn't
(00:36:20)
give them a cookie before dinner you
(00:36:22)
know and a 2-year-old fors a tantrum and
(00:36:24)
you can't handle it I think you know
(00:36:27)
I've talked about this before
(00:36:28)
then the child gets the message that in
(00:36:31)
order to be acceptable to the parent
(00:36:33)
they have to suppress their emotions so
(00:36:35)
when these people talk about that and
(00:36:38)
that suppression of emotion as I've
(00:36:40)
often made the case with you and in my
(00:36:42)
books actually under mying health and
(00:36:44)
and our physiology and our immune system
(00:36:47)
so when these people in their
(00:36:49)
dying weeks regret not having had the
(00:36:54)
courage to express their emotions what
(00:36:56)
they're really talking about is that
(00:36:58)
long time before when they were children
(00:37:02)
they were forced to suppress their
(00:37:04)
emotions for the sake of being accepted
(00:37:07)
yeah and now they regret it because they
(00:37:11)
they sense that they were forced to
(00:37:13)
abandon themselves and so again I would
(00:37:16)
remove the word
(00:37:17)
courage and ask instead of judging them
(00:37:20)
for lacking courage I would say what
(00:37:24)
happened to them because again no infant
(00:37:27)
left lacks the capacity to express their
(00:37:29)
emotions
(00:37:31)
yeah so if they lose it it's cuz they
(00:37:33)
learned that they had
(00:37:35)
to it terms of something practical
(00:37:38)
around this point gabo
(00:37:41)
if if there's any parents
(00:37:44)
listening and their kids let's
(00:37:47)
say sometimes get angry or have a
(00:37:51)
tantrum whatever it might be yeah of
(00:37:54)
course there is a certain conditioning
(00:37:56)
in our certainly in Western Society
(00:37:59)
about what one should do about that yeah
(00:38:03)
given your view in terms of what is
(00:38:05)
important for a child and what you've
(00:38:07)
just said what would you encourage a
(00:38:10)
parent to do when their child is I was
(00:38:13)
going to use the word playing up but
(00:38:15)
that's a ridiculous term because playing
(00:38:17)
up is a societal construct a child is
(00:38:21)
just expressing emotions we're calling
(00:38:22)
it playing up because we don't like you
(00:38:25)
know what it's doing or what the people
(00:38:28)
next door we're thinking or whatever it
(00:38:29)
might be right the North American drum
(00:38:31)
is acting out acting out yeah do they
(00:38:33)
use that phrase here yeah they do they
(00:38:35)
use this phrase H yeah so so going back
(00:38:37)
to that
(00:38:39)
um the parent who may be
(00:38:42)
struggling but wants to be a better
(00:38:44)
parent wants to go actually you know
(00:38:46)
what gab I really want to make sure that
(00:38:48)
I allow my child to express their
(00:38:50)
emotions yeah do you have any advice to
(00:38:52)
me what would you say to them no I do
(00:38:54)
well
(00:38:55)
so you know there's um
(00:38:58)
we can talk about three modes of
(00:39:00)
parenting one is the permissive
(00:39:02)
parenting where you allow any behavior
(00:39:04)
and you don't interfere you know that's
(00:39:07)
not that's the worst thing you can do
(00:39:09)
kids needs to but that is allowing them
(00:39:11)
to express themselves yeah but there's a
(00:39:16)
difference they might Express themselves
(00:39:18)
by hitting their sibling for example and
(00:39:20)
you don't allow that parents need to
(00:39:23)
kids need to feel that somebody's in
(00:39:24)
charge yeah parenting is not a democracy
(00:39:27)
it's a hierarchy
(00:39:28)
um in a hierarchy there's a dominant
(00:39:31)
Force the parent dominates the child not
(00:39:34)
to exploit or to suppress but to nurture
(00:39:38)
and to support you know so that you know
(00:39:42)
you live in Manchester and I don't know
(00:39:44)
how cold it gets in Manchester but if
(00:39:46)
you have a one-year-old child they don't
(00:39:48)
get to vote on whether they get to crawl
(00:39:50)
outside in the wintertime in Manchester
(00:39:52)
you know naked you know the parents says
(00:39:55)
no you don't go outside naked you know
(00:39:56)
you have to get put clothes on that's
(00:39:58)
just how it is it's a hierarchy it's not
(00:39:59)
a democracy the one-year-old doesn't get
(00:40:01)
a vote okay and being going into the
(00:40:04)
slush and the snow in the middle of
(00:40:06)
December or whenever um so that's
(00:40:09)
permissive parenting that's not very
(00:40:10)
good U then there's repressive parenting
(00:40:13)
which some experts that we've talked
(00:40:14)
about
(00:40:17)
Advocate that's authoritarian
(00:40:20)
parenting in between him is the golden
(00:40:22)
mean so there's permissive parenting
(00:40:25)
here authoritarian parenting here then
(00:40:27)
there's authoritative parenting in the
(00:40:29)
middle authoritative parenting is I'm in
(00:40:31)
charge I know it's good for you um I'm
(00:40:34)
the authority um so I know what to do
(00:40:37)
with you so if a child is upset you say
(00:40:40)
oh you're upset you know you're angry
(00:40:43)
with Mommy momy wouldn't let you have a
(00:40:45)
cookie before dinner yeah you're really
(00:40:47)
upset about that yeah well come here I
(00:40:49)
know how you feel in other words you
(00:40:51)
validate the emotion you don't punish
(00:40:54)
the child for it and you hold the child
(00:40:56)
cuz the child needs to learn Le that
(00:40:58)
they can go through these difficult
(00:40:59)
emotions and get through them and still
(00:41:03)
be loved and still be loved yeah now
(00:41:05)
that doesn't mean you let them pull the
(00:41:07)
cat's tail or to break the break the
(00:41:10)
glass you know smash the furniture or
(00:41:14)
hit their sibling but it doesn't mean
(00:41:16)
you validate the emotions and you hold
(00:41:17)
them and then they learn ah and and
(00:41:21)
actually and when they it's also age
(00:41:25)
specific like there's no point saying to
(00:41:27)
an one and a halfy old Let's find let's
(00:41:31)
express it through words they don't have
(00:41:32)
the words but to 5-year-old you can say
(00:41:36)
can we find some words for your anger in
(00:41:38)
other words you can teach them to
(00:41:39)
express their emotions in ways that are
(00:41:43)
um socially appropriate yeah so at any
(00:41:47)
age you have to be age appropriate but
(00:41:49)
fundamentally you validate the emotions
(00:41:52)
and you hold the child and you make them
(00:41:55)
feel that you can have this emotions I
(00:41:56)
don't want you to behaving that way but
(00:41:58)
you can have the emotion and I'm not
(00:41:59)
going to reject you for it it's not that
(00:42:01)
hard and people do it intuitively
(00:42:04)
sometimes yeah and the impact of
(00:42:06)
parenting like
(00:42:08)
that will be felt for the rest of that
(00:42:13)
child's life well absolutely and that's
(00:42:15)
the key isn't it you look look around
(00:42:17)
Society it's very very hard to not make
(00:42:19)
the case that we have the set up
(00:42:23)
Society so that those early years are
(00:42:27)
where the kids get good nutrition they
(00:42:29)
have calm environments they have present
(00:42:33)
parents you know I'm always shocked at
(00:42:35)
the amount of leave that um people in
(00:42:39)
America get or mothers get in jobs in
(00:42:42)
America I think one of my
(00:42:44)
friends Partners in America got two
(00:42:46)
weeks off oh which which I I I what two
(00:42:49)
weeks off after giving birth well when I
(00:42:51)
researched the myth of normal I found
(00:42:53)
that 25% of women in the states go back
(00:42:56)
to work within 2 weeks of giving birth
(00:43:00)
which 25% of women now needless to say
(00:43:02)
this is both economically and racially
(00:43:05)
determined but it means that it's a
(00:43:08)
massive abandonment of the child yeah
(00:43:10)
because en from the point of view of the
(00:43:12)
development of enzymes in the child the
(00:43:14)
child's physiological unfoldment
(00:43:16)
psychological security they need the
(00:43:18)
mother for many many many many months
(00:43:21)
and you try and take an infant away from
(00:43:23)
a an
(00:43:25)
orangutang at two weeks and see what
(00:43:28)
happens yeah you know and uh in
(00:43:32)
fact they've done some very cruel
(00:43:34)
studies with monkeys that shows the
(00:43:37)
impact of maternal deprivation at those
(00:43:39)
early ages you know studies
(00:43:43)
that are terrible to read about yeah and
(00:43:46)
they prove what they prove that love and
(00:43:48)
contact and connection is important
(00:43:50)
something we should have known all along
(00:43:52)
but the point is that that's statistic
(00:43:55)
that 25% of women have to go back to
(00:43:57)
work within two weeks of work within two
(00:44:00)
weeks of giving birth it's a massive
(00:44:02)
abandonment of children the impact of
(00:44:05)
which will show up in their mental and
(00:44:06)
physical health decades on yeah and then
(00:44:09)
they wonder why there's so many
(00:44:14)
problems tomorrow is the yearly
(00:44:16)
prescribing lifestyle medicine course
(00:44:18)
that I've been running uh with a
(00:44:20)
colleague Dr a panga since 2018 and of
(00:44:23)
course you're going to be the guest
(00:44:24)
speaker tomorrow and I'm I'm really
(00:44:25)
excited that we're going to be able to
(00:44:28)
communicate with doctors and share your
(00:44:30)
work and how they can bring your work
(00:44:33)
into their practice it's really really
(00:44:36)
exciting one of the things I'm
(00:44:39)
[Music]
(00:44:40)
hoping you're going to be able to share
(00:44:43)
with the audience
(00:44:44)
tomorrow is what I think is the biggest
(00:44:48)
hole in medical school training if you'd
(00:44:51)
asked me 5 years ago I may have said oh
(00:44:54)
nutrition and sleep and we need to teach
(00:44:56)
doctors about the import s of this stuff
(00:44:58)
and we do yeah but if I had to choose
(00:45:02)
one thing that I think is the biggest
(00:45:06)
hole in medical training
(00:45:08)
today for me it's that doctors a lot of
(00:45:13)
doctors leave medical school without an
(00:45:15)
understanding that our emotions oh I see
(00:45:18)
what you're saying yeah that the
(00:45:20)
way we think holding on to anger
(00:45:24)
resentment not being able to forgive and
(00:45:26)
move on
(00:45:28)
I really don't feel within medicine
(00:45:29)
there's an understanding that this can
(00:45:32)
contribute to ill health yeah it's such
(00:45:36)
a gap and um I think both you and I have
(00:45:39)
had to discover it not as a consequence
(00:45:43)
but despite our medical education yeah
(00:45:45)
and uh when you're in practice and you I
(00:45:48)
mean as a family physician um we do have
(00:45:52)
an advantage over specialist colleagues
(00:45:54)
in that we know people before they get
(00:45:56)
sick yeah so we get to see who gets sick
(00:45:58)
and uh I couldn't help but notice that
(00:46:01)
people's emotional lives are so
(00:46:03)
intertwined with the physiological
(00:46:05)
health
(00:46:07)
and as you suggest nobody in medical
(00:46:10)
school told me that it's it's a huge gap
(00:46:14)
it it it also has to do with how we
(00:46:15)
relate to ourselves by the way because
(00:46:17)
the way doctors are trained is very
(00:46:19)
often very stressful and very um almost
(00:46:23)
traumatic in significant ways so that in
(00:46:27)
that's why I mentioned the word
(00:46:28)
self-care because in being trained to
(00:46:30)
stoically ignore ourselves we also are
(00:46:34)
dismissing the importance of emotions in
(00:46:36)
our clients yeah so that I wish there
(00:46:39)
was more emphasis in medical school on
(00:46:42)
dealing with our own stuff yeah for sure
(00:46:46)
and in conjunction with that therefore
(00:46:48)
the awareness of the importance of
(00:46:50)
people's emotional lives yeah and and
(00:46:53)
what's really interesting here is that
(00:46:55)
some of the great pioneers of medic
(00:46:58)
have known this all along and they've
(00:47:00)
said it hundreds of years ago
(00:47:03)
well je Martin shco who first described
(00:47:06)
multiple sclerosis said that this is
(00:47:08)
related to stress and grief and uh it is
(00:47:12)
statistically and according to studies
(00:47:14)
since then but he just saw it he didn't
(00:47:16)
you know and uh there's a Great British
(00:47:18)
surgeon James padet yeah you know padet
(00:47:21)
disease and he operated in on women with
(00:47:23)
breast cancer and he said that breast
(00:47:25)
cancer is indubitably related to
(00:47:27)
emotional factors that is so evident
(00:47:29)
that it's hard to ignore and so these
(00:47:32)
great pioneers said this and their
(00:47:35)
teachings have been completely ignored
(00:47:37)
yeah let's be really clear this is such
(00:47:39)
a delicate area for people
(00:47:41)
because many people perceive that as
(00:47:44)
fault and as blame I know you don't mean
(00:47:47)
it like that I don't mean it like that
(00:47:48)
when I talk about it either yeah but
(00:47:50)
often it's like what are you saying that
(00:47:52)
I did this to myself right you must have
(00:47:54)
had that before people must have said
(00:47:56)
that yeah yeah just just clarify that
(00:47:59)
for them please well really we've been
(00:48:02)
talking about it that the um suppression
(00:48:06)
of
(00:48:07)
emotion nobody's born with it and it's
(00:48:11)
not a lack of courage or wisdom it's a
(00:48:14)
programmed response to Childhood
(00:48:16)
experience so people have got the
(00:48:18)
message be before they uh had any choice
(00:48:22)
in the matter that if they are truly
(00:48:25)
themselves if they express who they are
(00:48:26)
their emot tions just like we've been
(00:48:28)
talking about they won't be accepted so
(00:48:32)
that's a programming that people um are
(00:48:35)
engrained in in their Early Childhood
(00:48:37)
how is that their fault yeah it's just
(00:48:39)
the way they adapted to the environment
(00:48:41)
necessarily as a matter of fact it was
(00:48:44)
an inevitable and unavoidable adaptation
(00:48:47)
because the alternative of being
(00:48:49)
rejected by their families or their
(00:48:51)
milar was not acceptable to a small
(00:48:53)
child so therefore Nobody Does this to
(00:48:56)
themselves
(00:48:57)
in any conscious or deliberate
(00:49:00)
sense what I can tell you is that when
(00:49:04)
people are diagnosed and they become
(00:49:06)
aware of these Dynamics they find that
(00:49:08)
liberating yeah so uh in the methon
(00:49:12)
normal I quote the um the American
(00:49:14)
singer shell Crow who was diagnosed with
(00:49:17)
breast cancer and she said that before
(00:49:19)
the diagnosis I was always pleasing
(00:49:21)
others and not expressing myself and
(00:49:24)
there was always a voice in my head that
(00:49:26)
I'm wrong and
(00:49:28)
I have to adjust myself to other
(00:49:29)
people's expect I'm paraphrasing her but
(00:49:31)
she but she said I've learned
(00:49:33)
differently now and now I'm really
(00:49:35)
paying attention to myself so again
(00:49:37)
that's this idea of disease as teacher
(00:49:38)
now Cheryl Crow wasn't born like that
(00:49:41)
and she didn't choose to be that way
(00:49:43)
that was her response to her upbringing
(00:49:45)
so nobody's being faulted here but we
(00:49:47)
are saying people if you allow that
(00:49:50)
disease to wake you up and to teach you
(00:49:53)
something you might have a whole lot
(00:49:55)
better life than you could have imagined
(00:49:57)
yeah I think this is really really
(00:50:00)
interesting we can first of all make the
(00:50:03)
case to people that emotions matter the
(00:50:06)
express the the ability to express your
(00:50:08)
emotions is important if you repress
(00:50:11)
them yeah it may well have some quite
(00:50:14)
severe physical consequences yeah so
(00:50:16)
let's say that a doctor accepts that
(00:50:19)
goes okay so what do I do with that well
(00:50:24)
what do doctors do with it well here's
(00:50:26)
the
(00:50:29)
thing it depends how you're oriented
(00:50:31)
like I'm kind of psychologically
(00:50:33)
oriented I've always been I've always
(00:50:35)
been interested in it um so for me it
(00:50:38)
was a
(00:50:39)
natural movement from Strictly focusing
(00:50:43)
on the physical symptoms to dealing with
(00:50:45)
the whole person another physician May
(00:50:49)
recognize the value of this but not have
(00:50:51)
the orientation to deal with it but at
(00:50:53)
least they can say to their clients
(00:50:55)
listen there's a lot of information so
(00:50:58)
when you come in with your rheumato
(00:50:59)
arthritis or your multiple sclerosis or
(00:51:01)
your chronic eczema or chronic migraines
(00:51:05)
or irritable ball syndrome or
(00:51:08)
inflammatory ball disease or whatever
(00:51:10)
you happen to present with there's a lot
(00:51:12)
of information now a lot of scientific
(00:51:14)
information information that uh shows
(00:51:18)
the connection between actually in fact
(00:51:20)
the unity of mind and body and the
(00:51:23)
inextricable relationship between the
(00:51:25)
immune system and emotions and so on I'm
(00:51:28)
not myself trained in that I'm going to
(00:51:31)
deal with the physical aspects of
(00:51:32)
illness I'm going to prescribe for you
(00:51:35)
the anti-inflammatories or the immune
(00:51:38)
suppressants or the steroids whatever
(00:51:41)
you happen to need to mitigate the
(00:51:43)
symptoms but can I send you to somebody
(00:51:45)
so you can talk about this stuff would
(00:51:47)
that interest you you know so you can do
(00:51:50)
that so we're not necessarily talking
(00:51:52)
about every doctor having to become an
(00:51:54)
expert on this but at least they should
(00:51:56)
be a aware of it so they can steer
(00:51:58)
people to a broader approach to their
(00:52:01)
illness number one number two there's
(00:52:03)
certain simple things any doctor can ask
(00:52:06)
like one of my books when the body says
(00:52:09)
no that's the title um and in the myid
(00:52:12)
of normal there's a chapter called but
(00:52:14)
before the body says no you can ask your
(00:52:16)
client it's a very simple question where
(00:52:18)
in your life are you not saying
(00:52:20)
no who doesn't know that wants to be
(00:52:23)
said but you're not saying it for the
(00:52:25)
sake of pleasing others can you just
(00:52:27)
consider that one because that simple
(00:52:30)
issue of not saying no can play Havoc
(00:52:33)
with your health because if you're not
(00:52:35)
saying no when when you when you're
(00:52:39)
wanting to say no you're actually
(00:52:41)
suppressing yourself and then you're
(00:52:44)
taking on more stress and more burden so
(00:52:46)
those simple questions any doctor can
(00:52:48)
ask so it's not as complicated as all
(00:52:51)
that yeah but the point is the first
(00:52:54)
step is just to be aware of the
(00:52:56)
connection that mentioned between
(00:52:58)
emotions and
(00:52:59)
Physiology then if the physician wants
(00:53:02)
to take on a deeper study of it they can
(00:53:04)
if they don't at least they can guide
(00:53:07)
people to to to to to explore that
(00:53:10)
connection somewhere else yeah
(00:53:11)
completely agree thank you yeah fourth
(00:53:14)
regret I wish I stayed in touch with my
(00:53:17)
friends yeah well what we're talking
(00:53:21)
there is and it goes back to the others
(00:53:24)
about working too hard you know for
(00:53:26)
example um what are what are they
(00:53:29)
discussing there is the need for
(00:53:31)
attachment for connection for
(00:53:33)
belonging and what these people are
(00:53:35)
saying is I was too driven by whatever
(00:53:39)
factors impelled me to ignore my
(00:53:42)
personal relationships and to P my
(00:53:45)
attention on things that ultimately
(00:53:47)
don't
(00:53:48)
matter my acquisition my attainment my
(00:53:53)
achievement uh rather than the heart-to-
(00:53:56)
heart human contact with people that
(00:53:59)
matter to me and
(00:54:02)
again people are driven to be that way
(00:54:05)
and when they look back on their life
(00:54:07)
they regret it because nobody is is
(00:54:12)
often be said nobody ever on a deathbed
(00:54:16)
regrets not going to the office often
(00:54:19)
enough but they do regret the heart
(00:54:21)
connection that that that they'
(00:54:24)
sacrificed have you stayed in touch with
(00:54:26)
your
(00:54:28)
friends well you know uh that's where
(00:54:31)
you could say that I haven't um I mean I
(00:54:33)
have more much more recently it it
(00:54:36)
matters to me much more now but over the
(00:54:38)
years um I put work and my busyness and
(00:54:43)
my writing ahead of all
(00:54:47)
that is it at all balanced out by the
(00:54:50)
fact that your work and your writings
(00:54:54)
yeah have influenced the lives of
(00:54:57)
millions of people I guess what I'm
(00:55:00)
trying to get at
(00:55:02)
is on a personal level you may have
(00:55:05)
sacrificed your friendships
(00:55:08)
yeah but perhaps the world has benefited
(00:55:13)
from Dr mate doing
(00:55:15)
that is is that fair to say it's fair to
(00:55:18)
say and to some extent I accept that
(00:55:22)
that I've made certain decisions and
(00:55:24)
those decisions have benefited many and
(00:55:27)
it means that there's certain things
(00:55:28)
they missed out on um but not
(00:55:32)
completely and uh I'm much more prone
(00:55:37)
now to seek out those friendships and to
(00:55:41)
strengthen them and to celebrate them
(00:55:43)
and to Value them and I I I have some
(00:55:45)
really good friends you know and the
(00:55:46)
people that really care about me and I
(00:55:48)
care about them and we're there for each
(00:55:49)
other no matter what you know so that
(00:55:51)
matters to me much more than it used to
(00:55:54)
and uh to put it to the
(00:55:57)
test if I were to choose to live my life
(00:56:00)
over again I wouldn't live it in this
(00:56:02)
way yeah I
(00:56:04)
would say yeah I I have some insights I
(00:56:08)
have some capacity to articulate some
(00:56:10)
truths uh that are really important and
(00:56:14)
I'm not going to let that dominate how I
(00:56:17)
live my
(00:56:18)
life um and I think it would have been
(00:56:21)
possible for me
(00:56:23)
to express that voice and and and and to
(00:56:29)
put those teachings out to the world
(00:56:31)
that I get the feeling feedback that it
(00:56:34)
does help a lot of people but I could
(00:56:36)
have done that without the drivenness
(00:56:38)
without the sacrificing of the heart
(00:56:42)
without the and and connection that
(00:56:44)
sometimes that entails so you know again
(00:56:47)
if I could live it do it over again I
(00:56:50)
would do it differently and I don't
(00:56:51)
think in the end that would have
(00:56:53)
detracted from my message and if it did
(00:56:56)
I would accept accept that
(00:56:58)
yeah to make sure you're taking action
(00:57:01)
after watching this video I have created
(00:57:03)
a free breathing guide that's going to
(00:57:05)
help you reduce stress calm your mind
(00:57:07)
and boost your energy in this guide I
(00:57:10)
share with you six really simple
(00:57:13)
breathing practices that work
(00:57:15)
immediately even just one minute a day
(00:57:18)
will start to make a big difference to
(00:57:20)
receive your free guides all you have to
(00:57:22)
do is click on the link in the
(00:57:24)
description box below one is I wish I'd
(00:57:27)
let myself be happier yeah what does
(00:57:30)
that
(00:57:31)
say well that always reminds me of
(00:57:34)
because I mentioned Dr pep and his
(00:57:37)
concept of the brain circuits yeah one
(00:57:39)
of them is for play and
(00:57:42)
joyfulness and
(00:57:45)
um do you know winner the Poo yeah okay
(00:57:49)
not
(00:57:51)
personally the book uh and uh that was
(00:57:56)
me my favorite books and uh I've talked
(00:57:59)
about this before the end of that book
(00:58:02)
would bring tears to my eyes for years
(00:58:05)
because How It Ends is Christopher Robin
(00:58:08)
by the way that's a whole other thing
(00:58:10)
the relationship between a mil and his
(00:58:12)
son Christopher was a very fraud and
(00:58:14)
difficult one right and and Christopher
(00:58:16)
actually resented the books because he
(00:58:19)
felt that his father was buying these
(00:58:22)
toys to write about rather than for his
(00:58:24)
own benefit wow oh they had a very diff
(00:58:26)
there photograph of the two of them and
(00:58:28)
the kid is looking so alienated he had a
(00:58:29)
tough life and but that's a whole other
(00:58:32)
story but the book in in the book
(00:58:34)
Christopher Robin the little boy now has
(00:58:36)
to go to school yeah and he has to learn
(00:58:39)
about history and factors and
(00:58:42)
Mathematics and so on and he's telling
(00:58:44)
his friends the toy animals that he
(00:58:46)
won't be able to play with them so much
(00:58:50)
anymore and in the end Christopher and
(00:58:54)
Winnie the bear of little brain uh who's
(00:58:59)
the smartest of the whole lot and they
(00:59:01)
walk off together and the the book ends
(00:59:03)
with the statement something like and
(00:59:06)
whatever they do or wherever they go in
(00:59:08)
the Enchanted Forest a little boy and
(00:59:10)
his bear will always be playing together
(00:59:13)
and that phrase would bring tears to my
(00:59:15)
eyes for
(00:59:18)
years because play is so important and
(00:59:22)
joy is so important and that's what
(00:59:24)
these people are talking about and they
(00:59:26)
didn't allow themselves to experience it
(00:59:28)
they sacrific to play in the joy for all
(00:59:31)
these other
(00:59:32)
things you know and so
(00:59:35)
um the good thing is you know um I mean
(00:59:39)
my marriage the best thing you know what
(00:59:41)
the best thing in my marriage is the way
(00:59:42)
we play together the first time I dated
(00:59:45)
my wife Ray I knocked on the parents'
(00:59:48)
door and I said can Ray come out and
(00:59:51)
play and we've been doing it ever since
(00:59:54)
and
(00:59:55)
so um
(00:59:57)
um I believe what's being described in
(00:59:59)
that last regret is people sacrifice
(01:00:02)
their playfulness yeah their joyfulness
(01:00:05)
for the sake of being accepted and being
(01:00:07)
successful and all that it's a huge one
(01:00:10)
play is built into our
(01:00:12)
brains kids play spontaneously infants
(01:00:16)
play M and um in that
(01:00:21)
sense we can all be win the Pooh and and
(01:00:24)
Christopher we can always keep playing
(01:00:26)
in the Enchanted Forest and that's just
(01:00:30)
essential I
(01:00:31)
think in that final regrets is the word
(01:00:35)
happier yeah what does happiness mean to
(01:00:39)
you uh really it means the capacity to
(01:00:42)
play and to be in the present moment and
(01:00:44)
and and and and you know the kids when
(01:00:46)
when kids play they don't worry about
(01:00:48)
the
(01:00:49)
the appropriately they don't worry about
(01:00:52)
the war wherever or or climate change
(01:00:56)
just playing in the moment they're fully
(01:00:58)
present to themselves in imaginative
(01:01:02)
almost hypnotically imaginative States
(01:01:05)
so happiness just means being in the
(01:01:06)
present and being allowed to be no
(01:01:08)
matter what to have the capacity to
(01:01:11)
play a lot of people today gabo and I
(01:01:14)
think you have struggled with this as
(01:01:16)
well from what I
(01:01:17)
know feel with so much heartache and
(01:01:20)
suffering in the world yeah they feel
(01:01:23)
that they have no right to be happy
(01:01:26)
what's your take on that
(01:01:29)
well
(01:01:30)
um first of
(01:01:33)
all Bob Dylan said somewhere that it's
(01:01:36)
difficult to be completely happy when
(01:01:37)
other people are suffering it's true so
(01:01:41)
what this this is a time of terrible
(01:01:43)
suffering you know how I feel about Gaza
(01:01:45)
and the terrible things that are
(01:01:46)
happening there how can I be completely
(01:01:49)
happy I can't be completely happy I
(01:01:51)
can't because I can't not think about
(01:01:54)
that the horror of it
(01:01:57)
um but at the same time and this is
(01:02:02)
why people might
(01:02:04)
start get weirded out but I'm talking
(01:02:06)
about a psychedelic experience this is
(01:02:09)
three or four years ago I did
(01:02:12)
uh I worked with psychedelics both as a
(01:02:15)
Healer but also as a subject and I was
(01:02:18)
having a mushroom
(01:02:20)
experience and the same thing would
(01:02:22)
happened with AOS
(01:02:25)
once and
(01:02:26)
I've always been one that felt that how
(01:02:30)
could I be happy when asit is possible
(01:02:33)
when as what happened when my
(01:02:35)
grandparents perished there how can I be
(01:02:38)
happy what right do I have to be happy
(01:02:40)
if that can happen in the world and that
(01:02:42)
did happen in the
(01:02:44)
world and both the plants showed me at
(01:02:48)
some point that happened and yes you can
(01:02:52)
be happy that the one doesn't detract
(01:02:55)
from the other that that the capacity to
(01:02:59)
be empathetic and to recognize the grief
(01:03:02)
and to hold the grief does not obviate
(01:03:05)
the capacity to be happy and one doesn't
(01:03:08)
one does not one is not
(01:03:10)
disloyal to the suffering in the world
(01:03:13)
by allowing ourselves to be happy so
(01:03:15)
there's no necessary contradiction and
(01:03:18)
I I've seen people on death
(01:03:23)
row who if they win their appeal
(01:03:26)
the best thing they can hope for is life
(01:03:28)
in jail without life in prison without
(01:03:32)
parole but they're happy and how do they
(01:03:36)
become
(01:03:37)
happy
(01:03:39)
meditation working through their
(01:03:42)
traumas having remorse for what they did
(01:03:45)
connecting with other people and just
(01:03:48)
connecting with the present moment and
(01:03:50)
I'm thinking my God if people in that
(01:03:53)
situation can be genuinely happy which
(01:03:55)
I've seen
(01:03:57)
i' I've had contact with the people then
(01:03:59)
who am I to say that I can't be happy
(01:04:02)
yeah so so there's ultimately there's no
(01:04:04)
contradiction yeah now in this Society
(01:04:07)
there's way too much emphasis on you
(01:04:09)
know don't worry be happy Let's ignore
(01:04:11)
all the bad stuff that's going on let's
(01:04:13)
just concentrate on how we can make
(01:04:14)
ourselves pleased or or pleasured or
(01:04:17)
whatever I'm not talking about that no
(01:04:19)
I'm talking about being able to hold
(01:04:21)
both at the same time yeah you have to
(01:04:22)
and this is something I feel I've really
(01:04:25)
grown into the last years that I
(01:04:27)
actually can be very happy and content
(01:04:30)
yeah whilst there is heartache in the
(01:04:32)
world it doesn't mean I don't care I
(01:04:35)
actually deeply care yeah but I realized
(01:04:39)
that it's real skill it's an evolution
(01:04:42)
of the self to be able to hold those two
(01:04:44)
yeah I really do think that I think it's
(01:04:46)
growth that's right I very much love the
(01:04:50)
phrase uh that's attributed to
(01:04:52)
Gandhi be the change you want to see in
(01:04:55)
the world
(01:04:57)
yeah I I live I try my best to live my
(01:05:01)
life by that and why that's relevant to
(01:05:03)
this part of the conversation is I said
(01:05:06)
this once at a live event I said listen
(01:05:07)
if you watch the news and you allow this
(01:05:09)
is a few years ago allow the heartache
(01:05:11)
that's going on in name the country
(01:05:13)
right to affect you so much so that you
(01:05:18)
develop apathy you can't interact with
(01:05:21)
your husband with your children you you
(01:05:24)
you just drink more and more alcohol
(01:05:26)
even to numb your pain yeah what does
(01:05:28)
that do yeah right you're no good to the
(01:05:31)
people who are suffering you're no good
(01:05:34)
to those people around you and that then
(01:05:35)
ripples to everyone around you whereas
(01:05:38)
if you can learn to be content where
(01:05:41)
you're at yeah if you then do want to go
(01:05:44)
and help in whatever way you're much
(01:05:46)
more able to you know volunteer send
(01:05:48)
money whatever it might be yeah so I I
(01:05:52)
think this is I think this is a really
(01:05:53)
important point for people especially
(01:05:55)
the way things are in the world at the
(01:05:57)
moment a lot of people feel I've got no
(01:05:59)
right to be happy yeah well I I no
(01:06:01)
longer believe I used to believe that
(01:06:03)
and somebody once said to be sent to me
(01:06:05)
don't be so loyal to your
(01:06:08)
suffering and um that's a lesson I've
(01:06:11)
had to learn fairly late in life yeah
(01:06:14)
um and as I quote in the midth of normal
(01:06:18)
my friend Bessel Vander the trauma uh
(01:06:22)
psychiatrist looked at me once this is
(01:06:24)
about 10 12 years ago we having lunch
(01:06:26)
and he said gaboy you don't have to drag
(01:06:29)
arit around everywhere you go and what
(01:06:32)
he meant by that is that you don't have
(01:06:35)
to let that affect your present moment
(01:06:37)
that you can be aware of it hold a
(01:06:38)
memory of it but not let it determine
(01:06:42)
your internal States you know and and
(01:06:45)
it's true and I I understood
(01:06:46)
intellectually at that time what he
(01:06:48)
meant but it was only later that it I
(01:06:49)
was actually able to emotionally let go
(01:06:53)
let's just talk about forgiveness then
(01:06:55)
because a lot of the time people
(01:06:58)
say you know I just can't forgive what
(01:07:01)
what happened to me was wrong yeah now I
(01:07:05)
accept what happened to someone could
(01:07:06)
can be wrong yeah but it doesn't
(01:07:09)
necessarily follow that you can't
(01:07:12)
forgive yeah what's your take on
(01:07:14)
forgiveness well you and I last night we
(01:07:16)
were talking about a woman that be both
(01:07:19)
mad and admire tremendously Edith Edgar
(01:07:22)
yeah and Edith as I told you was 16
(01:07:26)
years old when I was one year old she
(01:07:30)
lived in a town in what is not Southern
(01:07:32)
Slovakia then was Northern Hungary
(01:07:35)
called Kasha or kosit and her family
(01:07:38)
were taken to
(01:07:39)
owitz and
(01:07:42)
um my grandparents would have been
(01:07:45)
either on the same shipment to ushitz or
(01:07:47)
within the next day or
(01:07:49)
so and her parents perished and she
(01:07:52)
survived with her sister and she's
(01:07:55)
become this psychotherapist she's
(01:07:57)
written a couple of wonderful books that
(01:07:58)
I know you've met her and interviewed
(01:07:59)
her and in one of her books she
(01:08:01)
describes going to the burkhoff in
(01:08:03)
Bavarian Alps where Hitler used to have
(01:08:06)
his lair and he went there she went
(01:08:08)
there to forgive
(01:08:10)
Hitler and
(01:08:12)
[Music]
(01:08:13)
um it doesn't mean that it was okay what
(01:08:16)
he did she did that to liberate herself
(01:08:19)
she didn't she said I don't want to keep
(01:08:21)
him in his prison in my heart for the
(01:08:22)
rest of my life I've worked too hard to
(01:08:25)
attain happiness and joy to let this
(01:08:28)
tension and this constriction control me
(01:08:31)
so the Forgiveness
(01:08:33)
wasn't making okay or or
(01:08:38)
pardoning Hitler for
(01:08:40)
his for all the evil that he perpetrated
(01:08:43)
in the world but is her letting
(01:08:45)
go of the emotions around it and of the
(01:08:49)
tension and the tightness around it so
(01:08:52)
forgiveness is not for the other person
(01:08:55)
it's for yourself
(01:08:58)
now when I work with
(01:09:00)
forgiveness I don't advise people to
(01:09:03)
forgive in fact as a matter of
(01:09:08)
fact I do the opposite I say to
(01:09:13)
people before you forgive allow yourself
(01:09:15)
to feel the full anger that's in you let
(01:09:18)
you let yourself fully experience the
(01:09:20)
anger that's there because once you
(01:09:23)
do it'll dissipate you let go of it so
(01:09:27)
don't do it in order to forgive do it in
(01:09:30)
order to liberate yourself
(01:09:33)
now let's say I was abused as a
(01:09:37)
child but let's say I find myself fully
(01:09:41)
liberated present oriented in contact
(01:09:45)
with
(01:09:46)
myself human being then what does that
(01:09:49)
mean it means nothing was taken away
(01:09:52)
from me it means that whatever happened
(01:09:55)
caused me a lot of pain over the years
(01:09:57)
but it didn't limit my capacity I wasn't
(01:10:00)
robbed of anything so what's there to
(01:10:03)
forgive so uh yeah and and and you can
(01:10:08)
also ask
(01:10:09)
yourself or anybody when you haven't
(01:10:12)
forgiven what's in your heart what's in
(01:10:14)
your body do you like that state that
(01:10:17)
you're
(01:10:18)
in uh the tension do you like that is
(01:10:22)
that how you want to be do you think
(01:10:23)
that's really helping you so I don't go
(01:10:26)
my way to teach now I know that in a lot
(01:10:27)
of spiritual practices there are
(01:10:29)
forgiveness practices and I know in
(01:10:31)
Buddhist practice and lot of spiritual
(01:10:34)
practices there forgiveness meditations
(01:10:36)
and prayers my mind doesn't go there but
(01:10:39)
my mind does say I I always have to
(01:10:43)
experience all the rage all the hatred
(01:10:45)
all the anger that's in you and be with
(01:10:47)
it and see what happens to it yeah and
(01:10:50)
what happens to it once you pay
(01:10:52)
attention to it it actually
(01:10:57)
dissipates and so when Edith goes to the
(01:11:00)
burov to forgive Hitler she's just
(01:11:02)
saying I don't want to hold on to this
(01:11:04)
stuff anymore it's not okay what you did
(01:11:06)
but I don't want to hold on to this
(01:11:08)
stuff anymore yeah it's it's fascinating
(01:11:11)
I think
(01:11:12)
curiosity
(01:11:15)
is is often a very helpful Pathway to
(01:11:18)
forgiveness because if you get curious
(01:11:21)
about that other person to why did they
(01:11:24)
act that way mhm I'm not talking about
(01:11:26)
Hitler here I'm talking about yeah
(01:11:28)
anyone but even with Hitler yeah what
(01:11:30)
what were the conditions in that
(01:11:33)
person's life that led to that if I was
(01:11:36)
that person I'd be behaving in exactly
(01:11:38)
the same way because I would have had
(01:11:40)
their parents and their childhood
(01:11:41)
experiences and they're bullying etc etc
(01:11:44)
exactly once you look at the world
(01:11:46)
through that
(01:11:48)
lens your initial approach becomes
(01:11:52)
compassion forgiveness comes as a
(01:11:56)
side effects of getting curious that's
(01:11:59)
totally right and there's an expression
(01:12:01)
that you may be familiar with which goes
(01:12:03)
to understand is to forgive yeah and uh
(01:12:06)
it begins with curiosity yeah so I and I
(01:12:09)
think that that curiosity is the
(01:12:11)
essential quality that actually leads to
(01:12:14)
compassion in the end now compassion
(01:12:16)
doesn't mean tolerance of bad behavior
(01:12:19)
no it doesn't mean validating or
(01:12:21)
justifying crimes against um nature
(01:12:25)
crimes against other human beings but it
(01:12:28)
takes away that quality of tension where
(01:12:30)
you make yourself Superior to reality
(01:12:33)
and you may and you put yourself in a
(01:12:34)
position to judge reality you know and
(01:12:37)
I'm above it and I'm in a position to
(01:12:38)
judge that's not a comfortable I mean
(01:12:41)
actually it is comfortable for a lot of
(01:12:43)
people to be there but it's a way of not
(01:12:45)
dealing with their own stuff so I do
(01:12:47)
think that curiosity is the key just to
(01:12:50)
wrap this conversation up Gabel we've
(01:12:52)
been talking a lot about these regrets
(01:12:54)
the regrets of dying yeah
(01:12:58)
and the final question I want to put to
(01:13:00)
you
(01:13:01)
is about the word
(01:13:06)
regret I have been playing with the idea
(01:13:09)
over the last 12 months or so that
(01:13:11)
regret is actually a form of
(01:13:15)
perfectionism so I actually now very
(01:13:17)
much subscribe to the philosophy of no
(01:13:19)
regrets but not in the not in the kind
(01:13:21)
of derogatory way you I'm going to live
(01:13:23)
my life my way it doesn't matter who
(01:13:24)
comes to my way
(01:13:26)
no with this really compassionate
(01:13:27)
understanding that I've always done the
(01:13:29)
best that I can yeah based upon where I
(01:13:32)
was in life at that time yeah so even
(01:13:36)
the things that I look back on and go
(01:13:38)
actually you know what if I was in that
(01:13:41)
situation again today I would act
(01:13:43)
differently I don't see them as regrets
(01:13:46)
I see them as situations that happen
(01:13:49)
that have taught me something which is
(01:13:50)
allowing me to be a better version of
(01:13:52)
myself today exactly so in my life today
(01:13:55)
there's there is no room for regret
(01:13:59)
anymore and I guess I would love to know
(01:14:01)
you know right at the end here what's
(01:14:03)
your perspective on the word regret
(01:14:07)
um I think um chronic regret is
(01:14:11)
debilitating um it's a lack of self
(01:14:13)
forgiveness it's um also kind of egotism
(01:14:17)
of that that that that that somehow that
(01:14:20)
important um it's quite something to
(01:14:23)
recognize I do recognize
(01:14:26)
that some of the way I parented my kids
(01:14:28)
the way I showed up I've often talked
(01:14:29)
about this in your program too wasn't
(01:14:32)
the best for them but it was the best I
(01:14:34)
could do at the time so it's not the
(01:14:37)
question of justifying but it's also not
(01:14:39)
dwelling on the past regret is to dwell
(01:14:43)
on the past and what's the point it's
(01:14:46)
quite something to
(01:14:48)
recognize that I did things that had I
(01:14:52)
known differently I would not have done
(01:14:53)
the same way that's just
(01:14:56)
learning um regret is an emotional state
(01:15:01)
of that values the past more than the
(01:15:04)
present and it um accuses
(01:15:09)
yourself
(01:15:10)
[Music]
(01:15:12)
of doing things for which you had no
(01:15:16)
consciousness to do otherwise so that's
(01:15:19)
where I stand with the greate yeah K
(01:15:21)
well you know what a big fan I am of
(01:15:23)
your work um it's just incredible to see
(01:15:26)
the
(01:15:26)
impact you're having on so many people
(01:15:29)
around the world I'm very lucky to
(01:15:31)
consider you a friend these days it's
(01:15:33)
been great to get to know you over the
(01:15:34)
last few years
(01:15:36)
um for someone who has heard us speak
(01:15:41)
today and something connected with them
(01:15:44)
something you said spoke to them and
(01:15:47)
they thought wow yeah you know what I'm
(01:15:49)
carrying around old stuff with me
(01:15:51)
today I don't express my emotions I'm
(01:15:54)
not living a life that is true to me
(01:15:58)
yeah what are some of your final words
(01:16:00)
for them well it's the word that you
(01:16:03)
used
(01:16:05)
curiosity
(01:16:06)
so not why am I living this way but hm
(01:16:11)
why am I living this way you know what
(01:16:13)
happened to me what am I carrying here
(01:16:15)
so uh the key phrase is precisely the
(01:16:18)
one that you introduced the necessity to
(01:16:21)
be curious yeah um in a compassionate
(01:16:24)
way so you you don't do an interrogation
(01:16:26)
of yourself like you're um Prosecuting
(01:16:30)
detective of why did you or why did you
(01:16:32)
not but
(01:16:34)
compassionately why did you not yeah why
(01:16:37)
did you and if you ask these questions
(01:16:41)
compassionately um and with curiosity
(01:16:45)
the answers will emerge as will the
(01:16:48)
capacity for you make yourself for you
(01:16:50)
to make different choices As you move
(01:16:51)
forward so where there wasn't Choice
(01:16:54)
before cuz you were compelled hel
(01:16:56)
or or or driven now you can have some
(01:17:00)
Freedom if you're willing to be curious
(01:17:02)
so curiosity is the word yeah gab all
(01:17:06)
your books are fantastic if someone is
(01:17:09)
at the start of their gab M Journey yeah
(01:17:11)
which book would you direct them towards
(01:17:13)
well you know um that depends on what
(01:17:17)
they're dealing with you know I mean if
(01:17:18)
they're interested in addiction
(01:17:20)
specifically they should read my book on
(01:17:21)
addiction or parenting they should read
(01:17:23)
hold on to your kids but if they want to
(01:17:25)
get the overall picture of the package
(01:17:28)
you know it's it's the certainly the
(01:17:29)
most recent the myth of normal in which
(01:17:31)
I combine pretty much everything I knew
(01:17:34)
at the time that I wrote it and I
(01:17:35)
already was only published a year and a
(01:17:38)
half ago it's been published now in 40
(01:17:42)
countries and 38 languages it's been a
(01:17:44)
best seller in a number of countries
(01:17:47)
that's the one I would start with um but
(01:17:49)
if you're interested in specific topics
(01:17:52)
then seek out the like ADHD you should
(01:17:55)
read scattered you should I would invite
(01:17:57)
you to read scattered Minds you know uh
(01:17:59)
so it just depends what you're dealing
(01:18:01)
with but if you want an overall
(01:18:03)
immersion in what I have to say it's the
(01:18:06)
myth of normal that's what which what I
(01:18:08)
would say the myth of normal over 1
(01:18:10)
million copies sold it says on this one
(01:18:12)
it's been a Smash Hit around the world
(01:18:14)
it's a great book Gabel thanks for
(01:18:16)
coming back on the show thank you I hope
(01:18:18)
to do it again if you enjoyed that
(01:18:21)
conversation I think you are really
(01:18:22)
going to enjoy this one about the top
(01:18:25)
five regrets of the dying and what we
(01:18:27)
can learn from them I spent eight years
(01:18:29)
looking after dying people and the most
(01:18:32)
common regret during those eight years
(01:18:34)
was I wish I'd lived a life true to
(01:18:36)
myself not the life that other people
(01:18:38)
expected of me
